Sample report · fictional brand
Should Mirna launch two toothpastes in Croatia?
The format of a Decision Report: the verdict on page one, dated shelf prices, break-even, and what could not be verified. The brand and prices are fictional.
Version 1.0
- Market
- Croatia
- Products
- two 75 ml toothpastes
For the whole team: all eight sections.
Verdict
Verdict
Launching at a shelf price of EUR 3.99, through a distributor, is supported only if the budget carries 14 months.
The three reasons
- At EUR 3.99 the tube stands sixth of eight by price, above the drugstore pastes and below the pharmacy and natural ones.
- Each tube leaves EUR 0.70 after production. At EUR 3.49 it would leave EUR 0.46.
- Break-even comes after about 14 months. The launch budget carries 12.
What would change the answer
Sales of 1,200 tubes a month, confirmed in writing by the distributor, bring break-even inside 12 months and move the verdict to Go.
AK Market Research receives a share of sales if the client launches. The fee for this report is the same regardless of the verdict.
A verified · B estimated · C assumption
Market size
The premium end of the category is worth about EUR 6.8 million a year.
| Estimate | How it is built | Result | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| From households down | 1.4 million households × EUR 25 a year on toothpaste × 20 % spent on tubes above EUR 3.00 | EUR 7.0 million | B |
| From shops up | 1,800 shops that list a premium toothpaste × 18 tubes a week × 52 weeks × EUR 3.90 average price | EUR 6.6 million | C |
| Working figure | Midpoint of the two estimates | EUR 6.8 million | B |
The two estimates differ by EUR 0.4 million. The first counts tubes bought in pharmacies and online, which the second covers only in part.
Mirna’s plan of 1,000 tubes a month at EUR 3.99 is about EUR 48,000 a year, under 1 % of the working figure.
Fictional example. Every figure is invented.
Shelf prices
Seven comparable toothpastes of 75 to 100 ml, observed in five shops in Zagreb on a single day. Unit prices are shown per 100 ml. Shops are identified by type only.
| Product | Shop type | Pack | Shelf price | Per 100 ml | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brand A, mint | Discount | 75 ml | EUR 1.49 | EUR 1.99 | A |
| Brand B, whitening | Supermarket | 75 ml | EUR 1.99 | EUR 2.65 | A |
| Brand C, herbal | Supermarket | 100 ml | EUR 2.49 | EUR 2.49 | A |
| Brand D, mint | Drugstore | 75 ml | EUR 2.99 | EUR 3.99 | A |
| Brand E, whitening | Drugstore | 75 ml | EUR 3.49 | EUR 4.65 | A |
| Brand F, sensitive teeth | Pharmacy | 75 ml | EUR 4.29 | EUR 5.72 | A |
| Brand G, natural, no fluoride | Organic shop | 75 ml | EUR 4.99 | EUR 6.65 | A |
Where EUR 3.99 sits
Mirna at EUR 3.99
Price and pack
A 75 ml tube at EUR 3.99 keeps Mirna under the pharmacy and natural brands per 100 ml.
| Comparable tube, by shop type | Pack | Shelf price | Per 100 ml |
|---|---|---|---|
| Discount shop | 75 ml | EUR 1.49 | EUR 1.99 |
| Supermarket | 75 ml | EUR 1.99 | EUR 2.65 |
| Supermarket | 100 ml | EUR 2.49 | EUR 2.49 |
| Drugstore | 75 ml | EUR 2.99 | EUR 3.99 |
| Drugstore | 75 ml | EUR 3.49 | EUR 4.65 |
| Pharmacy | 75 ml | EUR 4.29 | EUR 5.72 |
| Organic shop | 75 ml | EUR 4.99 | EUR 6.65 |
Three pack sizes for Mirna
| Pack | Shelf price | Per 100 ml | What it does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 50 ml | EUR 2.99 | EUR 5.98 | The lowest shelf price, and the highest price per 100 ml of the three. |
| 75 ml | EUR 3.99 | EUR 5.32 | The size shoppers compare with. Recommended. |
| 100 ml | EUR 4.99 | EUR 4.99 | Lowest price per 100 ml, but the tube stands among the pharmacy brands. |
Fictional example. Every figure is invented.
Channels and distributors
Of EUR 3.99 on the shelf, EUR 1.82 reaches the producer; the drugstore supplier is the one to call first.
Who to call, in this order
- 1Drugstore chain supplier
About 300 drugstores nationwide
Mirna’s price sits inside its premium range, and it lists no Slovenian toothpaste. - 2National grocery wholesaler
Supermarkets and hypermarkets nationwide
It reaches the most shelves, but the shelf there sits mostly under EUR 2.50. - 3Pharmacy wholesaler
About 1,100 pharmacies
A good fit for the price, but it asks for dental association backing. - 4Coastal seasonal distributor
Shops and hotels on the coast
Summer volume, which no shop would confirm. - 5Online drugstore
Two web shops
A test of the price with no listing fee.
Distributors are named by type only in this sample. A client’s report names each company and gives its public business contact.
Fictional example. Every figure is invented.
Break-even
Calculated from Mirna’s own costs (invented), at the shelf price to aim for.
| Item | Per tube | Grade |
|---|---|---|
| Shelf price | EUR 3.99 | B |
| Without VAT (standard rate, 25%) | EUR 3.19 | A |
| Retailer pays (30% margin) | EUR 2.23 | B |
| Distributor pays (15% margin) | EUR 1.90 | C |
| Transport per tube | − EUR 0.08 | B |
| Mirna receives | EUR 1.82 | B |
| Production, tube and carton | − EUR 1.12 | C |
| Contribution per tube | EUR 0.70 | B |
Fixed launch costs of EUR 9,800 ÷ EUR 0.70 = 14,000 tubes, or about 14 months at 1,000 tubes a month.
Risks and early signs
Sales of 800 tubes a month, or a 10 % rise in production cost, each move break-even by three months or more.
| Risk | Likelihood | Effect on break-even | First sign | Where to look |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Production cost rises 10 %, to EUR 1.23 a tube | Low | About 3 months later | A new price list from the tube or filling supplier | Supplier quotes, each quarter |
| Sales are 800 tubes a month, not 1,000 | Medium | About 4 months later | The first two reorders are smaller than the first order | The distributor’s monthly order sheet |
| The distributor’s margin is 18 %, not 15 % | Medium | About 2 months later | The written offer differs from the phone quote | The distributor’s written terms, before signing |
| The listing fee is EUR 2,500, not EUR 1,500 | Low | About 1 month later | The chain’s buyer names a fee at the first meeting | The buyer’s listing terms |
| A competitor runs a promotion at EUR 2.99 | Medium | Each tube sold at EUR 2.99 leaves EUR 0.22, not EUR 0.70 | A promotion label on a comparable tube | A shelf check in the same five shops, each month |
| Unsold tubes are returned near the end of shelf life | Low | About half a month later at 3 % returns | Tubes with short dates at the back of the shelf | Date codes on the shelf, at each check |
Fictional example. Every figure is invented.
What could not be verified
A client’s report contains the same eight sections, with real shops, real dates and the client’s own costs.
The shelf answers either way. Ask it first.
The first step is a short brief covering the website, the products, label or pack photos, the target markets and the decision at hand. A reply follows within 3 working days: either an invitation to a free 30-minute call, or a clear statement that the brief is not the right fit. Nothing is payable before a contract is signed.